How Real Estate Secondaries Are Priced: NAV, Discounts, and Value

Pricing is the heart of any secondary transaction, and it is frequently misunderstood. Understanding how buyers arrive at a number—and why discounts exist—helps both sellers and prospective investors read the market clearly.

NAV is the starting point, not the answer

Secondary pricing is typically quoted as a percentage of the fund’s most recent reported net asset value (NAV). A price of “85% of NAV” means a buyer pays 85 cents for each dollar of reported value. But NAV is a starting reference, not the final word. Reported values can lag current market conditions, and buyers run their own underwriting—discounted cash-flow analysis, asset-by-asset review, and a view on where valuations are heading—to decide what a position is actually worth. It is often the case that several secondary investors already hold a position in the fund that is being sold. This facilitates the transaction as those buyers have already been approved by the GP, and they have already performed valuation and due diligence on the fund.

Why interests trade at a discount

Discounts to NAV are common, and there are rational reasons for them. A discount compensates the buyer for providing liquidity to a seller who wants out of an otherwise illiquid position. It also reflects the quality and age of the underlying assets, uncertainty about future performance, and the time and cost of holding the investment. In recent years, real estate secondary discounts have often been wide—averaging close to 30% since 2022 by some measures—because sellers needed liquidity in a market where direct property sales had slowed. Discounts widen in stressed markets and narrow when confidence and competition among buyers return.

The bid-ask spread

Deals happen only when buyers and sellers agree on price. The gap between what sellers hope to receive and what buyers are willing to pay—the bid-ask spread—drives transaction volume. When the spread is wide, activity slows; as it tightens, volume tends to pick up. Watching the spread is one of the better ways to gauge the health of the secondary market.

What actually drives returns

The discount is eye-catching, but it is not usually the main source of return. Across the secondary industry, most gains historically have come from appreciation of the underlying assets rather than from the initial purchase discount. In other words, buying at a discount helps, but the performance of the buildings themselves matters more over the life of the investment. A cheap entry price into a deteriorating asset is not a bargain.

A note on the J-curve

Because secondary buyers acquire seasoned portfolios that have already moved past their early, fee-heavy years, secondaries can soften the J-curve—the early period when a primary fund shows negative returns—and return capital sooner. That distinct cash-flow profile is a large part of why investors allocate to the strategy.

This article is provided by PTB for general informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute investment, legal, tax, or accounting advice, and it is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security or investment product. Any examples are illustrative. Securities-related services are provided by PTB’s principals in their capacity as registered representatives of March Capital Corporation, a registered broker-dealer and member FINRA/SIPC.

Previous
Previous

Real Estate Joint Ventures: How Sponsors and Capital Partners Structure Deals

Next
Next

How to Sell a Real Estate Fund Interest: The LP-Led Secondary Process